Carpe Diem

Size of U.S. State Economies vs. Foreign Countries

We often lose sight of: a) how big the U.S. economy is, b) how productive American workers, and how much we produce vs. other countries. After all, who can get their mind around $13 trillion, the size of the U.S. economy measured by GDP ($13,000,000,000,000)?

World GDP is about $47 trillion according to the CIA World Factbook, so the U.S. economy produces more than 30% of world output every year, with just 5% of the world’s population. Reason: American workers are so productive compared to workers in other countries. That’s why per capita GDP in the U.S. is $43,500 vs. the world average of $10,000, and why many single U.S. states are equal in size, or larger than, many foreign countries.

The fascinating GDP map above (click to enlarge) matches the size of state economies in the U.S. to the size of comparable countries. You can view GDP by state here, and GDP by country here.

For example, Texas GDP is about $1 trillion, equal to the entire GDP of Canada. Georgia GDP is $363 billion, approximately equal to the GDP of Switzerland. Mississippi GDP is $81 billion, a little bit smaller than the GDP of Chile last year ($95 billion), so the comparisons in the map might be approximate, not exact.

Genesee County (includes Flint, MI) where I live, produces roughly twice as much output annually with a population of 400,000 people as the entire country of Honduras produces with more than 7m people! The state of Michigan produces more output ($376 billion) with 10 million residents than the entire country of Turkey produces with 70 million people!

Thanks to Chapomatic for the pointer on the GDP map.

Carpe Diem

Disappearing Middle Class Graphically?

Do a Google searh of the exact phrase “disappearing middle class” and you’ll get 16,500 hits.

Think about what it would mean statistically or graphically if the middle class of Americans really did disappear. Assume that income is distributed somewhat normally like Distribution 1 above (technically it would actually be skewed to the right to account for the Oprahs, Tigers and Bills, as in Gates). If middle income households really did “disappear” wouldn’t we then have a) nobody left in the middle and b) two new distributions, one of low income households and one of high income households like the distributions above labelled “Low Income” and “High Income?”

Does anybody really seriously think that could ever happen in the U.S.?

Carpe Diem

Disappearing Middle Class?

We hear a lot of handwringing these days about the “disappearing middle class,” and how the benefits of the current economic expansion are going disproportionately going to “the rich.” How does the middle class of the U.S. compare to countries in Europe?

In the graph above from the blog Back Talk, those in the lowest 10% in the U.S. have about the exact same disposable income as those in the lowest 10% in Europe. At the other end of the scale, the highest 10% in the U.S. have much higher disposable incomes than the highest 10% in Europe. All of these measures are relative to the U.S. median disposable personal income (which is set to 100).

Are only the rich making off like bandits? Well, look at the middle class (i.e., look at the median). The European in the middle makes only about 73% of what the American in the middle makes.

That’s how America’s economy distributes its benefits across the economic spectrum (relative to other nations). Those at the bottom of our economic ladder are similar to those at the bottom of other industrialized nations. One would imagine that, in all of these nations, the government tries to ensure that the basic needs of the poor are satisfied (e.g., adequate food, uncrowded living conditions, plumbing, electricity, etc.) without going much further than that. But as you start moving up the economic ladder, you are better off here in America. And that would appear to be true starting pretty far down on that ladder (somewhere below the median for sure).
Carpe Diem

Got Any LPs?

Long-playing (LP) records are gathering dust in the homes of many music lovers (like me), who hope to hear their contents one day on a CD player or iPod.

Now, an updated version of another audio relic, the phonographic turntable, may provide a fairly inexpensive way to do that. Two new consumer turntables on the market at $200 or less connect directly to computers to transfer cherished vinyl to MP3 files and CDs.

Read more in NY Times.

Carpe Diem

Tax Subsidies for the “Rich?”

Federally backed student loans regularly go to the wrong people – in 2003-04, nearly 30% of students from families earning more than $100,000 a year got them – and they make tuition more expensive for everyone. And while federally subsidized loans – on which Democrats are now focusing after promising to cut rates on all federal student loans during the campaign season – go to fewer wealthy families, they still tend to benefit well-off students and those whose parents understand how to game the system.

Read more here.

Carpe Diem

What Do “Meatlifting” and Meth Have in Common?

Meatlifting is a grave problem for food retailers: According to the Food Marketing Institute, meat was the most shoplifted item in America’s grocery stores in 2005. (It barely edged out analgesics and was a few percentage points ahead of razor blades and baby formula.)

Meat’s dubious triumph is due in part to a law enforcement crackdown on methamphetamine use. Meat used to be the shoplifting runner-up to health-and-beauty-care items, a category that includes cough medicines containing pseudoephedrine, a key ingredient in home-cooked meth.

In 2003, for example, a quarter of shoplifted products were HBCs, while meat took second place at 16 percent. But states began passing laws that require stores to move medicines containing pseudoephedrine behind secure counters. That was enough to cut the pinching of HBCs, which fell by 11 percent between 2003 and 2005.

Read more here in Slate.

See Faces of Meth here, you won’t believe it.

Carpe Diem

Corn Prices Hit Ten-Year High at $3.95/bu

1. Ethanol is already one of the most coddled and protected industries in America. Before even pulling into the filling station American taxpayers have already paid between $1.04 and $1.45 in government subsidies for each gallon of ethanol, according to a report from the Global Subsidies Initiative. That adds up to an annual total of about $6 billion. Read more here in today’s NY Sun.

2. Skyrocketing prices for corn on the world market have pushed up the price of the humble tortilla, the mainstay of the Mexican diet, by nearly a third in the past three weeks, to 35 cents a pound in Mexico City and even higher in other parts of the country. Some economists blame the increased demand for corn from ethanol plants in the United States, and it is true corn prices in the States last week reached their highest point in a decade (see graph above). Read more from NY Times article Cost of Corn Soars, Forcing Mexico to Set Price Limits.

Carpe Diem

Detroit Public Teachers, Private School Choices


What would you conclude about the quality of product or service X under the following circumstances?

1. The employees of Airline X and their families are offered free airline tickets as an employee benefit. The employees refuse to travel with their families on Airline X and instead pay full fare on Airline Y when flying.

2. The employees of Automaker X are offered a company car at a substantial discount and they instead buy a car at full price from Automaker Y.

3. Employees at Health Clinic X and their families are offered medical care at no additional cost as a benefit and yet most employees of Clinic X pay out-of-pocket for medical services at Clinic Y.

In each case, the employees’ willingness to pay full price for a competitor’s product or service and forgo their employer’s product or service at a reduced price (or no cost) makes a strong statement about the low quality of X. What makes the inferior quality of X even more obvious is that the employees at Firm X, since they work in the industry, would have better information about product (service) X and product (service) Y than the average person.

What then should we conclude about the quality of public education in Detroit given the following facts? Public school teachers send their own children to private schools at a rate 50% higher than average–18.5% of public educators’ children in Detroit are in private schools compared to 12.8% for all families.

Read today’s editorial in the Detroit News here.

Carpe Diem

Quotes of the Day

“From the point of view of physics, it is a miracle that 7 million New Yorkers are fed each day without any control mechanism other than sheer capitalism.”

~John Holland, scientist, Santa Fe Institute

“I am convinced that if the market system were the result of deliberate human design, and if the people guided by the price changes understood that their decisions have significance far beyond their immediate aims, this mechanism would have been acclaimed as one of the greatest triumphs of the the human mind.”

~Friedrich Hayek, Nobel economist

“It is something of a miracle that individual selfish decisions (in a market economy) must lead to a collectively efficient outcome.”

~Steven Landsburg in the Armchair Economist

You May Also Like