Foreign and Defense Policy

No amnesty for Snowden

Image Credit:

Image Credit:

The Guardian reports that NSA officials are so worried about the documents Edward Snowden stole and may still release, they are actually considering offering him amnesty for their return:

National Security Agency officials are considering a controversial amnesty that would return Edward Snowden to the United States, in exchange for the extensive document trove the whistleblower took from the agency….

The NSA official in charge of assessing the alleged damage caused by Snowden’s leaks, Richard Ledgett, told CBS News an amnesty still remains controversial within the agency, which has spent the past six months defending itself against a global outcry and legislative and executive proposals to restrain its broad surveillance activities.

“My personal view is, yes, it’s worth having a conversation about,” Ledgett, who is under consideration to become the agency’s top civilian, said in an interview slated to air Sunday evening on 60 Minutes. “I would need assurances that the remainder of the data could be secured, and my bar for those assurances would be very high. It would be more than just an assertion on his part.”

Amnesty? Have they lost their minds? Snowden is a traitor to his country, who is responsible for the most damaging theft and release of classified information in American history. His actions have exposed not only the NSA terrorist surveillance programs, but our intelligence collection efforts against foreign governments, including Russia and China. He has aided our enemies, shared intelligence with potential adversaries, and has damaged our ability to defend against future terrorist attacks. Maybe we offer him life in prison instead of a firing squad, but amnesty? That would be insanity.

On NBC’s Meet the Press this Sunday, former CIA and NSA director Mike Hayden explained why amnesty would be a terrible idea:

I would strongly oppose that..  Look, I know there’s a great fear he’s got a lot more out there… I wouldn’t do it.  I understand the attraction, but I wouldn’t do it because that simply motivates future Snowdens to do these kinds of things.

Exactly. If Edward Snowden can get amnesty after what he has done, then who could ever be prosecuted for any intelligence leak? How could we possibly pursue charges against leakers for individual disclosures, however damaging, when someone like Snowden is allowed to get away with the largest disclosure of critical intelligence in our history?

If anything, amnesty would encourage leakers to share more information. The lesson will be: if you leak, leak big and you can get away with it. The more damaging the disclosure the better your chances to get off scott free.

Amnesty for Snowden is a terrible idea.

Follow AEIdeas on Twitter at @AEIdeas.

6 thoughts on “No amnesty for Snowden

  1. If Snowden is a traitor then all red blooded patriotic citizens are traitors to the uber state……..with out his revelations we would not even know of the un-constitutional actions currently being taken.
    Thiessen sets the bar so high for whistke blowers that the only ones he honors are the ones that turn their parents in to the government….oh well at least he is direct ion his support of FACISM….or maybe he does not know what facism looks like unless it wears a swastika.

  2. Marc, I really hope you are being facetious, but I suspect not. Both the Bush and the Obama administration have literally torn the US Constitution to shreds and here is a man with the cojones to stand up and blow the whistle on what these politicians have done and you want him PROSECUTED?

    I agree with you….. Snowden should NOT get amnesty….. In ADDITION to amnesty, he should also be awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom and then let’s throw in Obama’s Nobel Peace Prize on top of that.

    Sorry, Snowden is, IMPO, a true AMERICAN HERO and deserves much more than just amnesty but to see the those who have eroded our Constitution Rights prosecuted and thrown in jail, starting with Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld but continuing to to Obama, Holder and much of today’s congress, who are sworn to uphold the constitution.

    Dr. PDG, Jakarta, Indonesia

  3. Snowden is a hero. I would far rather see him as President than any Republican or Democrat. He is not a “traitor to his country” either. The traitors may be found enthusiastically bleating on behalf of the State-which is not the same thing as our country.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>